Cases
Heroes Technology v. Consumer Product Safety Commission
CASE SUMMARY
NCLA asks the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit to stay the Consumer Product Safety Commission’s mandatory Safety Standard for Infant Support Cushions regulating Heroes Technology’s one-of-a-kind Snuggle Me Infant Lounger and thousands of other products.
The Consumer Product Safety Act allows CPSC to use an expedited rulemaking process when it promulgates mandatory safety standards governing durable products for children under 5 years old, like cribs or strollers. If the product is not a durable infant or toddler product, it must follow the traditional, more exacting regulatory process. CPSC used the expedited durable goods process to create its new Rule for “infant support cushions,” a product category that did not previously exist. But Snuggle Me Infant Loungers, a product made of organic cotton and polyester fiber that parents use to gently hold their infants, are textiles, which are not generally considered durable goods. CPSC thus had no authority to promulgate the mandatory rule governing these products using the expedited process. Congress has stated it prefers voluntary product safety standards, yet the Rule allows CPSC to claim power over a major market segment instead of crafting product-specific voluntary standards with Heroes Technology and other eager industry partners.
Despite Heroes Technology and others raising serious concerns about producers’ ability to redesign their products and apply new and ill-defined testing methods as the Rule requires, the agency declared the regulation would be effective on May 5, 2025, just 180 days after it was promulgated. This was certainly not “reasoned decisionmaking” by CPSC, making the Rule arbitrary and capricious under the Administrative Procedure Act, which requires agency actions to be “reasonable and reasonably explained.” The Snuggle Me Organic Infant Lounger is highly regarded and sought after by parents and caregivers. Heroes Technology has taken costly steps to comply with the Rule, but the product may still be eliminated.
RELEVANT MATERIALS
NCLA FILINGS
Opposed Motion for Stay Pending Review
March 13, 2025 | Read More
Record of Consumer Product Safety Commission Action
March 5, 2025 | Read More
Re: Supplemental Request to Postpone the Effective Date of Safety Standard for Infant Support Cushions, 89 Fed. Reg. 87,467 (Nov. 4, 2024)
February 20, 2025 | Read More
Re: Request to Postpone the Effective Date of Safety Standard for Infant Support Cushions, 89 Fed. Reg. 87,467 (Nov. 4, 2024)
February 6, 2025 | Read More
PRESS RELEASES
NCLA Asks D.C. Circuit to Stop Consumer Product Safety Comm.’s Illegal Infant Support Cushion Rule
March 14, 2025 | Read More