Amicus Briefs
Starbucks Corporation v. McKinney
CASE SUMMARY
The National Labor Relations Board deprived Starbucks of property without due process of law via an administrative enforcement proceeding, utilizing a preliminary injunction it obtained without even establishing that the company likely broke the law. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit upheld the district court injunction per a textually baseless doctrine that allows an employer to be punished based on legal and factual allegations falling far short of meeting the ordinary preliminary injunction standard. The New Civil Liberties Alliance urged the U.S. Supreme Court to reverse the Sixth Circuit’s error and overturn the injunction.
The Supreme Court has made clear, in a variety of statutory contexts, that federal courts may not issue preliminary injunctions unless the party seeking the injunction has met four requirements. It must establish that: (1) it is likely to succeed on the merits; (2) it would suffer irreparable injury absent an injunction; (3) the balance of equities favors an injunction; and (4) an injunction serves the public interest. Yet, five federal circuit courts, including the Sixth Circuit, apply a far more relaxed standard when NLRB seeks a preliminary injunction against an employer. They uphold an injunction if NLRB’s claims are not frivolous—even if they are more likely than not meritless—and where it serves NLRB’s remedial powers, even if it inflicts disproportionate burdens on the employer.
The National Labor Relations Act does not support this practice, and it defies the Fifth Amendment’s guarantee that no property shall be taken without due process of law. Under the Sixth Circuit’s approach, NLRB can obtain a punitive injunction forcing Starbucks to retain and pay unwanted employees for an indefinite period—without the government having to prove even a likely violation of law.
In June 2024, the Supreme Court overturned the Sixth Circuit’s decision, a victory for NCLA.
OUR TEAM
RELEVANT MATERIALS
NCLA FILINGS
PRESS RELEASES
Seven Supreme Court Victories Underscore NCLA’s Success in Limiting Unlawful Administrative Power
August 19, 2024 | Read More
In NCLA Amicus Win, Supreme Court Overturns NLRB-Specific Preliminary Injunction Standard
June 13, 2024 | Read More
NCLA Amicus Brief Asks U.S. Supreme Court to Reject NLRB-Specific Preliminary Injunction Standard
February 28, 2024 | Read More
In NCLA Amicus Win, Supreme Court Will Hear Case Against NLRB’s Odd Prelim Injunction Standard
January 12, 2024 | Read More
NCLA Amicus Brief Asks Supreme Court to Hear Case Challenging NLRB’s Unfair Injunction Standard
November 7, 2023 | Read More
IN THE MEDIA
A Watershed Supreme Court Term Will Not Drown The Administrative State
June 6, 2024