Media Room
Commentary
Post Search
Brand X deference advances ‘administrative absolutism’
When Justice Clarence Thomas dissented from the denial of certiorari last week in Howard and Karen Baldwin v. U.S., he lamented that “Brand X has taken this Court to the precipice of administrative absolutism.” Given that Thomas himself authored NCTA v. Brand X Internet Services in 2005, the case that launched the Brand X judicial deference doctrine, this turnabout…
Read
The Games Bureaucrats Play: FCC Streamlined Hearing Rule—Balderdash
Michael P. DeGrandis
The Federal Communications Commission is proposing a new regulation to “promote more efficient resolution of hearings.” The Procedural Streamlining of Administrative Hearings Rule, as the FCC calls it, claims that none of its hearings require oral testimony. For decade after decade and Commission after Commission, the FCC has held trial-like adjudications with oral testimony pursuant…
Read
Why You Should Clerk for NCLA
Jessica Thompson
NCLA is fighting on the front lines of cutting-edge administrative law litigation–and you have an opportunity to be a part of that fight! NCLA is the nation’s only public interest law firm dedicated solely to litigating administrative law issues and restoring respect for our civil liberties. A clerkship with NCLA is an unparalleled opportunity…
Read
Can an Agency Rewrite the Law to Ban an Entire Industry Overnight? Maybe in New York
Caleb Kruckenberg
One of the most pernicious tools used by the administrative state is the court-created doctrine of agency “deference.” Roughly, this doctrine says that administrative agencies are entitled to interpret ambiguous laws any way they want, and courts are required to accept that interpretation even if the court wouldn’t read the law the same way.…
Read
AXON v. FTC Will Put the Administrative State on Trial
Adi Dynarcategory_listJohn J. Vecchione
There is a case of importance and promise for injecting Constitutional protections in proceedings by administrative agencies. Faced with a recalcitrant Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”), AXON Enterprises, Inc. (“AXON”) sued the FTC in federal court on January 3, 2020 seeking declaratory and injunctive relief from the process that the FTC plans to use against…
Read
It’s Time for Agencies to Adopt the Brady Rule in Civil Enforcement Actions
Kara Rollins
In Brady v. Maryland, the Supreme Court first recognized that a defendant’s due process rights are violated when a prosecutor fails to disclose material exculpatory evidence, evidence tending to show that a defendant is not guilty of a crime or punishment. The Brady Court found that criminal defendants have a constitutional right to the disclosure…
Read
Media Team
